14 Unreliable German Cars To Avoid (Specific Models & Years)

German automakers, especially Audi, BMW, Mercedes, and some others, are reputable for producing high-quality vehicles. However, when it comes to reliability, not all vehicles of German descents score a high mark.

In this article, we present 14 unreliable German cars to avoid. Let’s check them out one after the other.

1. Mercedes-Benz C-Class

The Mercedes-Benz C-Class is one of the few luxury cars that offers zippy acceleration while delivering a remarkable fuel economy. However, some of the C230 and the C-300 model years are unreliable.

The Mercedes-Benz C230 is one of the C-Class series introduced by Mercedes in 1993. Most German automakers are notable for producing compact cars, and the C-Class is one of the famous names in the market.

Of course, it is a compact executive car available in different variants. With 5 generations in its lineup, the Mercedes-Benz C-Class offers high-quality ranges of compact rides.

However, not all the vehicles under the C-Class lineup are reliable. In particular, you may want to avoid the 2007, 2003, 2004, and the 2005 Mercedes-Benz C230 model years, especially the 2007 version.

So, what could be wrong with this C230 model years? Read further to discover.

The Mercedes-Benz C-Class is one of the leaders in its class in terms of ride quality, especially when you consider the handling and response of the steering. However, many of the old models do not offer impressive engine performance.

Engine problems, drivetrain issues, and faulty fuel propulsion system are the most notable issues with many old C230 models. And these issues are most common with the 2007 model year.

To mention just a few, a number of owners of this car have complained about the engine failure, particularly the unreliability of the balance shaft.

Similarly, the 2015, 2016, 2008, 2009, and 2010 Mercedes-Benz C300 are also not reliable. Aside from the common engine problems, they also have issues with their fuel propulsion system and electrical components.

Check out our post on the best & worst years for Mercedes-Benz C-Class to learn more about the problems with the car.

2. BMW X Series

Indeed, BMW boasts of many flawless and highly reliable vehicles, like the M series, i-series, and a number of several others.

However, critics and reviewers have labelled a few BMW cars, such as the 2013 X3, 2011 X5, and the 2013 X5, as the worst models. What could be wrong with these models?

The 2013 BMW X3 does not come with the best exterior design, but it boasts a high-quality cabin and capacious space for both passengers and cargo. However, it just has a lot of daunting issues with the engine, the drivetrain, and the electrical system.

No one loves to experience stalling while driving, especially on a lonely highway. Or do you?

Well, this is an issue you may likely experience, amongst several others, when you drive the 2013 BMW X3. Aside from the unexpected stalling of the vehicle, other notable issues with this SUV include faulty time chain and engine failure.

Like the 2013 X3, the 2011 and 2013 BMW X5 have also proven to fail in terms of guaranteeing reliable engine and overall vehicle performance.

Unlike the X3, several other X5 model years are also unreliable judging by the number of complaints consumers have given about them.

Precisely, you should also be wary of the 2001, 2006, 2008, 2009, and the 2012 BMW model years.

3. BMW 3 Series

The BMW 3 Series offers an exciting ride quality complemented by an upscale cabin. However, some of the 328 and 325 models are not as reliable as the other 3 Series models.

The BMW 328 works with a six-speed manual transmission and offers a rear-wheel drive as standard. It also features all-wheel drive and a six-speed automatic transmission as optional features.

However, consumers have criticized a few of its model years for recurring time chain problems and erratic engine performance.

A number of BMW model years have suffered from a faulty time chain and fuel propulsion system. Unfortunately, the 2014, 2013, 2011, 2009, 2008, and the 2007 BMW 328 are all serious victims.

Moreover, most of the BMW 325 model years have also proven to be unreliable in similar regards. So, you should also be mindful of the 2006, 2004, 2003, 2002, and the 2001 BMW 325 model years.

4. Audi A4

Audi is one of the most revered German automakers; so, more would always be expected of them in terms of overall vehicle performance.

Unfortunately, the Audi A4 is Audi’s vehicle that has received the highest number of user complaints on Car Complaints as of the time of writing this article. Out of over 270 complaints, note that the engine is the major point of concern.

You won’t love to drive a car with excessive oil consumption knowing fully well the significance of engine oil in vehicle performance. Well, with this ride, you may get to deal with that.

Indeed, the Audi A4 has offered better models in their more recent model years. However, you should beware of the engine of the 2017 down to the 2002 model years, except for the 2016 and 2015 models that have proven to fare better over the years.

5. Audi Q5

Many automakers always got it wrong with the very first set of vehicles they produce. It seems Audi is also a victim of this early imperfection syndrome.

Like the Audi A4, the Audi Q5 also has a lot of issues with many of its earliest models.

This small and finely-built SUV offers a roomy cabin while standing as Audi’s best-seller. However, it seems its engine is not very different from that of the A4.

Like the Audi A4, many owners and drivers of the Q5 have also complained about excessive oil consumption and faulty time chain.

There have also been a series of concerns about the power steering failure of this SUV. That said, you’d better avoid the 2014, 2012, and the 2013 Audi Q5 model years.

You should also be wary of the 2018, 2016, 2015, and the 2011 model years.

Learn more about the best & worst Audi Q5 model years to gain more insights on the vehicle’s issues.

6. Mini Cooper S

Although Mini is, originally, an asset of a British Automaker, the Bayerishe Moteren Werke (BMW) group became the owner since 2000. In case you’re in doubt if Mini is also a German car, we believe this has answered the question, right?

Back to the main discourse, the Mini Cooper S boasts BMW-engineered suspension and steering, while offering loads of safety features. It also works with an automatic soft top that makes driving more fun.

However, its seats are less comfortable, and the base model gives off a slow speed. This car runs with a 1.6-liter four-cylinder engine that makes only 115 horsepower, which is significantly below par when compared with the modern day’s standard.

Besides, the Mini Cooper S is also notorious for erratic transmission response and unexpected engine failure. Water pressure failure, oil leak, and timing chain slippage are also common issues with the Mini Cooper S.

Mind you, these issues are not peculiar to all Cooper S models. They are common to the 2009, 2007, 2006, and 2008 model years.

7. Mini Cooper

An exciting delight of Mini is that most of its models have received little to no consumer complaints over the years. The brand just seems to have gotten a number of things wrong with the Coopers.

Like the Cooper S, the Mini Cooper also boasts a number of impressive features. It offers a nimble handling and an impressive fuel economy. However, its overall ride quality is quite lackluster.

According to Edmunds, the ride quality of this vehicle can be ‘stiff and jittery’, especially when you decide to switch to larger tires.

This can’t be less obvious, as over 571 consumers have complained about the steering of the 2005 Mini Cooper alone. A most notable issue in this regard is the power steering failure.

Besides, overheating and transmission failure are other common issues with the Mini Cooper.

You should note, however, that these problems are not peculiar to all Cooper model years. They are most pronounced in the 2005, 2006, 2007, 2009, and the 2010 model years.

For more insights on the problems with the car, check out the 10 best & worst years for the Mini Cooper.

8. Some Volkswagen Models

Volkswagen is also amongst the notable German automakers known for producing high-quality vehicles. Having being in existence since 1937, this brand has produced a number of remarkable vehicle models.

However, you can hardly rely on many of the Passat, Jetta, CC, Beetle, Tiguan, and even the Volkswagen Golf model years.

In particular, the 2010, 2012, 2009, 2011, and the 2013 Volkswagen CC are known for recurring issues with the engine and fuel propulsion system.

Similarly, the 2003, 2002, 2006, 2004, 2013, 2014, and 2012 Volkswagen Passat all have known issues with the engine, brake, transmission, electrical, and fuel system.

Their issues are similar to those found in the 2006, 2003, 2002, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, and the 2019 Volkswagen Jetta model years.

Also, in addition to the common engine and transmission issues with this make, body defect is a major added issue with the 2004, 2006, 2000, 2003, 2001, and the 2007 Volkswagen Beetle.

The Volkswagen Tiguan and the Golf fares somewhat better in this regard. However, consumers have also reported a number of issues with the engine and electrical system of the 2009, 2010, and the 2011 Volkswagen Tiguan.

And, due to the common issues with the engine coolant and the fuel propulsion system, you might also want to avoid the 2015, 2017, 2005, 2001, and the 2010 Volkswagen Golf model years.

Make sure you also check out our article on the 9 typical issues with German cars.

Was this article helpful?